If the battle for Skype were a television series, it would have been equal parts soap opera and suspense thriller. It nearly segued into courtroom drama, but it wouldn’t have been a good one, likely way too one-sided for engrossing fare.
In the end, it was the specter of a courtroom rout that got the principals to the table to hammer out a settlement that leaves a few people happy, a few people content, and a few people disconsolate. There were winners, losers, and those who fall somewhere between those unambiguous extremes.
I think Om Malik has done an excellent job categorizing how the various players fared. His blunt assessment is keenly accurate, cutting through the cant and dishonest spin of those who would try to persuade us that we can trust neither our own lying eyes nor our critical faculties.
As far as the official breakdown, eBay finally gets to sell majority ownership of Skype to a consortium of investors, though the composition of those investors — and the overall percentage of the company they’ll take off eBay’s hands — has changed.
The key paragraph, excerpted from the press release announcing the settlement, is this one:
“As part of the settlement agreement, Joltid and Skype founders Niklas Zennström and Janus Friis will join the investor group, contributing Joltid software and making a significant capital investment in exchange for a 14 percent stake in Skype. As a result, Silver Lake and other investors including Andreessen Horowitz and the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board (CPPIB), will together hold 56 percent of Skype and eBay will retain 30 percent. As previously announced, eBay will receive approximately $1.9 billion in cash upon the completion of the sale and a note from the buyer in the principal amount of $125 million. The deal, which values Skype at $2.75 billion and is not subject to a financing condition, is expected to close in the fourth quarter of 2009.”
In the original ill-fated arrangement, announced September 1, eBay sought to sell 65 percent of Skype to a consortium of investors that was led by Silver Lake. That consortium included Index Ventures but excluded Skype’s founders, Zennstrom and Friis, who — by the time this story runs its course — will have been both sellers and buyers of Skype in separate transactions with eBay.
Like the doomed proposal that preceded it, today’s announced agreement values Skype at about $2.75 billion.
Index Ventures and Mike Volpi, a partner in that firm, are not part of the deal. Index would like us to believe that this arrangement occurred entirely of its own volition, but the evidence suggests otherwise. Here is what Danny Rimer, a partner at Index Ventures, had to say about the Skype settlement:
“We are pleased that Skype will now be able to put litigation behind it, and we wish Josh Silverman, his team and the Skype investors well in continuing to grow a great business. Although Skype has the potential to be a great investment, the deal terms changed for Index such that it no longer matches our investment criteria and thus we have decided not to participate in the transaction.”
Om Malik contends rightly that this is . . . er, poppycock.
I don’t know whether Index could have said anything to take the sting out of the loss it sustained, on multiple fronts, in this whole Skype imbroglio. Nonetheless, the quote Rimer provides is embarrassing and ungracious. There are times when it’s best to say nothing, and this qualified as one of them.
It’s all over but the shouting now. With 23 directors, Skype might want to soundproof the boardroom.